moot✳
A little more connected.
Join Moot

If you want to know who survives AI, look at what happened to Hollywood in the 1970s.

Movie Studios used to enforce tight “shooting ratios”; usually 5:1, maybe 10:1 TOPS. As in, for every 5 feet of film shot, at least 1 foot had to end up in the final cut (35mm was expensive!)

In the 70s, there was a rapid elimination of production constraints. Improvements in film cost and camera portability made the old studio rules…obsolete. Why not take multiple angles, roll simultaneously? Set could have 3, 5, even 10 cameras rolling at once. Shooting ratios exploded, 50:1, even 100:1 (Apocalypse Now)!

Of course, it also radically changed the workflow. Editing use to be the quiet, thankless job in the studio years (30s-50s). Suddenly, they became the most important people on the totem pole!

How do you find the masterpiece hiding in the (literal miles) of film? A ton of the footage was…trash, of course. But as each individual camera because less important, it opened up directors to take on significantly higher risks.

Now, don’t get me wrong. Insane shooting ratios were still kinda a niche in the 70s. More traditional directors stuck with only slightly inflated shooting ratios (15:1, 30:1 common); it was the more experimental pioneers (Coppola, Scorsese, etc) that hit the big 100:1 numbers. The huge ratios were still crazy.

Until they weren’t.

You can probably guess what happened in the early 2000s. Digital cameras reduced the cost of individual footage to a complete non-constraint. Effectively free, don’t even cut on set, just keep the camera rolling.

Suddenly…EVERYONE starts shooting 100:1. Entire new forms of content get created, like Reality TV, where ratios can hit 500:1! Massive shift of human labor to the editing side.

I’d say, we’re currently in the “1970s Hollywood” of AI. It can be easy (and cheap!) to produce things (code, tools, etc), but YOU have to be the ruthless editor. It’s the “miles of film” problem all over again. Hollywood solved it by throwing massively more resources on the editing side, and editing became a “constantly talking with the director about vision/direction” job, instead of a “hide in the back office and do your work” job.

It’s a hunch, but I’d bet that filmmakers closer to the experimental 1970s “ratio explosion” directors handled the later 2000s digital shift much better, because the underlying principles were the same. They’d certainly be ahead of the curve predicting it, and (hopefully) were less surprised when the digital ratios did hit.

I’m not saying AI is exactly the same problem. But it’s a good idea to look at parallels in history where rapid elimination of constraints changed an industry, and how that industry handled it 5, 10, even 50 years later!

When something starts to get cheap…helps to imagine what would happen when it’s free!

#ai#filmmaking#technology history#future of work
1
5 comments
5 comments

Hi. No offense, but this is completely wrong. I actually worked on one of the first major studio movies to ever use a digital camera. I was literally on set and in post during the exact transition you're writing about. Although digital cameras do allow filmmakers to record for longer, they did not change the amount of footage being captured to a meaningful degree. The reason it had little effect is because the process of making movies did not change very much when these cameras came to market. In fact, the digital cameras were much more like a drop-in replacement for film cameras than a complete reimagining of the production workflow. This was partly enforced by the strong union structure within the Hollywood system, but also has to do with the fact that the production process has been quite optimized over many decades of iteration. The cost savings of digital was also nominal. Studios were certainly happy to not have to pay for film stock, but at the end of the day that's a very small part to the overall budget of a Hollywood film.

Your rebuttal misses the entire point of the post, and is unnecessarily rude.

Yes, big Hollywood productions have relatively infinite money, hence someone like Coppola was able to shoot insane ratios before the digital era. But as I stated in my first line of the post…I’m talking about the 70s transition.

It’s a double hump. First it becomes possible, then it becomes cheap.

For someone like Coppola, the film->digital transition wouldn’t have been stark; those ratios were already normal for him.

It’s kind of like AI companies giving employees orders-of-magnitude more tokens to experiment with compared to the general public. A few years ago, 10 billion tokens used to be an unimaginable number. OpenAI used to give people trophies for that just a year ago! Now, 10 billion tokens is nothing. You can do it for $50. Certainly not trophy worthy.

There’s a trickle-down effect where much like digital filmmaking, a small budget production can eventually have shooting ratios that could only be dreamt about before.

The non-existence of reality TV prior to the early 2000s clearly demonstrates my point. There are entire categories of filmmaking that are only recently possible because of the relative cheapness of insane shooting ratios.