moot✳
A little more connected.
Join Moot

From the perspective of a caveman or even farmer from few hundred years back - most of our jobs (us city dwellers) are like UBI (universal basic income).

You cannot convince a 15th century person that what a typical MBA grad does is a legit profession, let along one of the highest paid ones.

In light of what is happening with AI - I have had an lightbulb moment - that Graeber’s “bullshit jobs” are actually a form of UBI. We need bullshit jobs to sustain the economy and the society.

Just growing food, packaging it and feeding the 8B people of earth needs just 1-2% of the population to do it. What will the rest 98% do?
Initial days of COVID lockdown showed us how the economy needs to constantly “move”. It collapses if stationery. If for even few weeks, people stop spending money, entire economy stalls, GDP free falls, everyone’s income becomes zero because everyone’s income after all comes from someone else spending money.

So when people say that “if AGI automated everything then we need UBI” I guess they are not realising that before AI there has been electricity, computers, Internet, industrial manufacturing and lots of other paradigm shifts that have already done a wave of “automate everything”, and the human race just went ahead and invented yet another hundred million bullshit jobs to keep the displaced population busy with something to keep the economy moving. And we will do exactly the same after AGI as well.

DDavid Shapiro (L/0)@DaveShapi

They're catching on.

View on X
#ubi#bullshit jobs#economy
0
1 comments
1 comments

The book Bullshit Jobs was an argument for UBI. He literally concluded his book with how UBI was the only solution he could see to fixing the BS jobs problem.