Are the App stores necessary? Or a necessary evil?
I have built a few web apps and they can install on phones as a PWA and behave on the phone just like an app downloaded from the app stores. If the user didn't know it was a PWA they would not likely be able to tell the difference in functionality.
Aside from the prospect of getting more eyes on the app and potential users from app store exposure, what are the other benefits?
TBH, the app stores irritate me a bit. They were created by the mobile OS platforms to make money off of developers in exchange for distribution. But the promise of distribution is no longer as big of a carrot as it used to be since the app stores are overrun with endless options today.
Not to mention the costs just to get an app listed. Google Play is reasonable in terms of costs to get an app on the app store (99/year).
In my opinion, the app stores were built in a time when web apps were not natively responsive in their design and so the mobile experience sucked on most web based apps. Now building responsive apps is so much easier and most look and work great on mobile without the need for the app store download.
The only real exceptions are when you need deep device integration that is blocked by the device maker except for through their sanctioned apps. However, this is a decision the device makers make on your behalf. They cite security concerns or feature functionality but we know big companies are gaining access to their locked down features to suit their own marketing or data collection purposes. I will say that the number of functions that are limited to app store apps is pretty small nowadays but it can still be a deal-breaker for just a PWA.
I guess they also serve as a vetting mechanism to keep crappy apps off your device but an app from the app store can still crash just as easily as a PWA web app can.
My intent here is to start a conversation. Should we, as developers, continue to support the mobile device app stores or not? Can web apps do just as well as app store apps today or not?
no. I am not making my apps available on iOS unless someone comes in and pays me 100 per year minimum. Fuck apple.
I'm seriously second guessing making our available on iOS now that I know $99 isn't a one time fee.