this type of post makes me very bearish on humanity.
I'm starting to discover a non negligible part of humanity appreciates slop? LLMs are incredibly good at some things, but talking about my essays right now is still at the level of slop.
This isn't a statement on future capabilities. It's just that I find it sad that current ones are taken to be at harold bloom level.
LSichu LuXView on Xthis is the funniest thing, if you actually read books you quickly realize the AIs of today are better discussion partners about classics than any human can possibly be. they have READ EVERYTHING. they put Harold Bloom to shame. all i have to say is that harvard freshman brains are scrambled so badly that they think Sparknotes-style is the only way of engaging with LLMs. yes llm lets you cheat if you want to and not read things, but they also offer people who like reading a depth of engagement about text that is 10x any collection of students/professors no matter how well read and intelligent. they can simulate the richest intellectual environments you can experience
I don't appreciate slop but books by definition are not good at explaining niche points of confusion specific to a user. They are fixed in time and not adaptive. In a dialog, you can go literally exponentially deeper in the rarity of your confusion. In things I'm an expert in, books are not great. In things I'm just learning and I'm a typical learner at, they are fine. I think that's a very different thing than appreciating slop.