moot✳
A little more connected.
Join Moot

Are tech layoffs really because of AI, or is AI just part of the story?

I don't think all these layoffs are happening just because of AI. I feel like there might be more to the story.

Recently, I came across a post from a PayPal employee who mentioned that after layoffs in their team, the remaining employees were expected to take over the work of the people who were let go. Even if the roles were still needed, the company wasn't necessarily hiring replacements.

I also recently spoke to a friend who works at a product-based MNC. According to him, the situation isn't just about AI replacing people. AI is definitely helping developers write code and complete tasks more efficiently, but he believes the bigger problem is the lack of new projects and clients. He mentioned that his company hadn't acquired a new client since 2024.

This got me thinking: Are companies actually laying people off because AI can do their jobs, or are they using AI as part of the explanation for broader economic problems, reduced business demand, and cost-cutting?

Another thing I wonder about is whether companies are reluctant to openly acknowledge that their business growth or demand has slowed down, especially when they need to maintain investor confidence and stock prices.

I'm not saying AI has no impact on jobs. It clearly has the potential to change how software development works. But I find it hard to believe that AI alone explains everything happening in the job market.

For those working in IT, especially in product-based companies:

  • What is the actual situation inside your companies?

  • Are layoffs happening because AI is genuinely replacing employees, or are they mainly due to fewer projects, reduced client demand, and cost-cutting?

  • Are companies still hiring, or are they simply making existing employees do more work with fewer people?

I'd genuinely like to hear perspectives from people working in the industry rather than just relying on headlines and corporate statements.

1
3 comments
3 comments

A lot of tech companies hired a lot of folks during covid. It was a necessarily low bar because qualified engineers were so scarce. A lot of places, including my own employer at the time, were doing three 30-minute interviews and then making a hiring decision on six figure jobs, because candidates with an English major and a six week frontend bootcamp would get hired out from under you if you took any more time to make the decision.

There’s a lot of folks hired in that era who offer really questionable value, and a lot of tech orgs are shedding those people and trimming their bloated headcount.

Ironically, now it’s the systems guys who are in really high demand due to all the datacenter/cloud buildout, and the software developers in demand during covid are being let go. I just spent a year hiring a sre in India with a certain in-demand specialty. I had two guys who accepted offers poached by nvidia and arm before their start date, then had to offer an inflated title to poach a guy from someone else and finally get an offer to stick.

I do not believe that, COVID was a long time ago. Those engineers were laid off in 2023-2024.

It's like 40 percent AI, 60 percent other factors like end of ZIRP, worse economy overall etc