moot✳
A little more connected.
Join Moot
C

cpz_77

@cpz_77

Social handles

Browse matching posts and comments already imported to Moot, including those shared before signup.

Developers who spent years building software before AI, how does the job feel now?

@cpz_77 · Reddit ·

Not sure that having a bunch of people build all this “amazing stuff” that they have no idea how it works is a good thing. I get what you’re saying , change happens, yes we have to deal with it, and there are definitely upsides. Part of the thing that made complex software impressive was exactly the fact that some humans had to actually think and work through every problem, bug, optimization, design decision etc. and many of these took many years to evolve into what they are today. Could an AI generate a fake copy that looks similar and appears to work on the surface? Sure, but without a human to point out the finer points to pay attention to, it will inevitably gloss over details which is why the final product will suck for the customer (and btw we’re already seeing that in commercial products, everywhere - it’s no coincidence that software is at an all time low).

So yes I get the upside and I agree it’s cool that doors are open for project we never would’ve had time to get to before…that’s all great. And I am trying to take advantage of it whenever possible. But I do think there are some very real, permanent downsides this will have on the software industry, and the world in general (to your point, it will and in fact already is impacting other industries the same way as well). Once the knowledge pool the current workforce has built up has cycled out as people retire and we have a full new generation of developers who never knew what it was like to write and maintain software by hand, where does that leave us?

IMO, there should be a “required knowledge level” barrier to do certain things because otherwise the result will be crap…which will manifest in the form of a bad experience for users at a minimum. Or worse , depending on what function the software serves. Do you trust Claude to maintain software that keeps people alive, or keeps planes in the air, etc.? If you want to build something big, you should have to spend the time learning and researching it…if you designed it, you should know it (and it’s internals) like the back of your hand. Eliminating that requirement isn’t doing anyone any favors.

This is why although the “anyone can do anything” idea might sound nice in theory, I don’t think it actually is going to work out very well for society.

@cpz_77 · Reddit ·

Precisely. That’s why things will get worse as more people who never learned those things and went through those struggles start trying to use AI to produce software.

@cpz_77 · Reddit ·

Have to say that’s surprising to hear places actually still doing that at this day in age with things are the way they are, but I totally understand it. And props to your place for not folding to the pressure of the world and diving in blind headfirst like everyone else did. IMO AI can be very helpful but definitely has long term consequences if we aren’t very careful. And as more developers without career experience that today’s veterans in the industry have start using it to produce stuff, they will be less informed of how to guide it/what to watch for when stuff goes sideways/etc. and results will suffer accordingly. And I’m not sure how you really gain that experience if you never spent time building software by hand…that’s why the future is very uncertain.

Will be interesting to see how things turn out - personally I think the bubble will pop and actual skilled developers will be back in demand (and value will hopefully be placed on actually taking the time to understand these concepts instead of always just pushing forward as fast as possible) but I think it will get worse before it gets better.

View conversation